The Four Gunmen Of The Holy Trinity Review

From The Spaghetti Western Database

Fourpistolstrinity.jpg


Review of The Four Gunman of the Holy Trinity (See database Page) by Tomas Knapko

I won't lie, I picked up this western because of its cool title. As a seasoned genre aficionado I thought I knew what to expect (cool titles often fail to deliver on its promises) so I wasn’t that disappointed when I found out there are no four gunmen of Holy Trinity, just Peter Lee Lawrence carrying a sawn-off lever action rifle – fine by me, unusual weaponry is the inconspicuous aspect of few spaghetti westerns, which can always elevate rating, if other aspects (like sloppy screenplay), didn't shoot straight.

  • Unimportant note no. 1) Recently, I've seen another Peter Lee Lawrence's western titled Death On High Mountain and you can bet there wasn't even one mountain in a whole movie. Sorry, hills are no mountains. Plenty of deaths though. Don't get me even started on PLL's God In Heaven... Arizona On Earth.
  • Unimportant note no. 2) To confuse things a little bit more, there ARE actually four gunmen in the beginning of the movie, but they should be six in proper number, very complicated matter these spaghetti westerns, just see it for yourself.

Anyway, Peter Lee Lawrence plays an ex-soldier George Shelley, now reporter heading for some reason towards the US/Mexican border, meanwhile chatting and playing a guitar with a recently befriended marshal (Phillipe Hersent), who is after some gun-trafficking low-lifes. Sooner than PLL can bewilder local fauna with another guitar solo, he has to put in use his rifle and unmount some highly suspicious riders pursuing a lonely woman, who recently has to live through some horrors that can happen in the Wild West. After some riding through snowy landscapes and explanations given why George Shelley rather uses dwarfed version of a Winchester rifle instead of a revolver, they all end up in an Inn amongst all kind of unusual characters following their own agendas.


Vlcsnap-2019-09-18-16h42m03s107.png

From this moment on, the movie takes place almost entirely in an interior of the hotel or surrounding area, so we can include this Giorgio Cristallini's first western effort among the indoor spaghetti western subgenre, combining such titles as Shoot The Living, Pray For The Dead (Vari), Stagecoach Of The Damned (Bosch), A Pistol For Ringo (Tessari) or Quinto – Fighting Proud (Klimovsky). Compared to Cristallini's second western You're Jinxed, My Friend, You've Met Sacramento with Ty Hardin it becomes apparent which one is more flawed and why. Somewhere in the middle of The Four Gunmen, things start, as it is often the case, to fall apart a bit: the characters seem to appear in a location they could hardly be present at the time, some protagonists choose more complicated resolution of a situation over simpler one, or we witness some weird transition between the scenes.

Examples:

  • 1) When PLL pursues a kidnapper on a horse and then confronts him, the midget pistolero (Salvatore Furnari) appears on the scene seemingly out of nowhere. I would only believe that if he sneaked onto the scene mounting a pony!
  • 2) Frenchie (Umberto Raho) deploys a plan to kidnap a person from the hotel, which means his henchmen wreak all kind of dynamite havoc outside to make a distraction, which allows him to knock out this person unconcious and slip her out of the window right into the evilicious arms of one of his men (that would be Raf Baldassarre). The whole building is so big, I doubt anyone would notice that he had done so without the add of exterior explosive turmoil. But alright, I get it, the whole venture wouldn't have to go so smoothly, the woman in question might scream and put Frenchie in jeopardy, so Frenchie's evil scheme is plausible.
  • 3) I'm willing to believe that Peter Lee Lawrence (or better said, his double) can jump down six meters from a rooftop without any harm, but not an elderly Marshal twice PLL's weight. Come on. Who's next? Salvatore Furnari? The eighty years old doctor?

These are minor issues anyway, the next one is a bigger problem.

  • 4) Once the incognito Marshall obtain informations from a wounded person (still in the hotel) of the real intentions of Frenchie and his companions, he gives the present doctor a revolver he can defend himself with and then the Marshall sneaks out of the building to find Shelley. In the next scene, confusingly, we see all residents, including the doctor (he should take the opportunity and jump those six meters), bound to the columns of a dining room, an evil deed surely executed by Frenchie and his colleagues in a mysteriously missing act.

Such a weird jump in the storytelling might put a viewer off, but since we are almost at the end, I recommend to endure, because once Peter Lee Lawrence picks up his sawn-off repeater we are about to witness highly enjoyable, dramatic and unpredictable finale, actually one of the best I've seen in the genre, which make you forgive the movie some of its previous shortcomings, which can be blurred even more in your mind by the atmospheric soundtrack by Roberto Pregadio (depends if you like jazzy style music) and absorbing cinematography of Alessandro D'Eva, creating almost otherworldly visual - there's a beautiful shot of a whole dining room with all the occupants present, a short scene which make you wonder in which way the fate of every single participating character will turn out to be eventually – but rather don't believe in happy endings this time.

Tomas' rating: 75%


FotobustaQuattro1.jpg FotobustaQuattro2.jpg FotobustaQuattro3.jpg

Director: Giorgio Cristallini - Cast: Peter Lee Lawrence, Ida Galli, Phillipe Hersent, Raf Baldassarre, Daniela Giordano, Valeria Fabrizi, Daniele Vargas, Umberto Raho, Raymond Bussieres, Tonino Pierfederici, Salvatore Furnari - Music: Roberto Pregadio


  • Newsletter
  • Giallo
  • Spaghetti Western books
  • Arrow Video