Buono, il brutto, il cattivo, Il/DVD: Difference between revisions

From The Spaghetti Western Database
Jump to: navigation, search
No edit summary
Line 1: Line 1:
''General comment:'' All recently released 2-DVD versions of this film by MGM are more or less identical. They vary in choice of language tracks offered, in packaging and in format (PAL/NTSC). They are all the same in terms of version and extras, so it is safe to say that you should order the version that suits you best.
''General comment:'' All recently released 2-DVD versions of this film by [[Global MGM DVD catalog|MGM]] are more or less identical. They vary in choice of language tracks offered, in packaging and in format (PAL/NTSC). They are all the same in terms of version and extras, so it is safe to say that you should order the version that suits you best.


<div style="padding:5px;margin:2px;border:1px solid gray">'''Special Edition features identical on all versions''': (Differences are noted under the specific disc)
<div style="padding:5px;margin:2px;border:1px solid gray">'''Special Edition features identical on all versions''': (Differences are noted under the specific disc)
Line 30: Line 30:
|[[Image:Leoneboxusa2.jpg|114px|right]]
|[[Image:Leoneboxusa2.jpg|114px|right]]
* ''This box set includes the re-release plus [[A Fistful of Dollars]], [[For a Few Dollars More]], [[Giù la testa|Duck, You Sucker]] (includes all 4 Special Editions)''
* ''This box set includes the re-release plus [[A Fistful of Dollars]], [[For a Few Dollars More]], [[Giù la testa|Duck, You Sucker]] (includes all 4 Special Editions)''
* Label: MGM
* Label: [[Global MGM DVD catalog|MGM]]
* '''Buy now: [http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B000OPOAMU/102-4288925-5607313?ie=UTF8&tag=spaghetti-western-20&creativeASIN=B000OPOAMU From Amazon.com] | [http://track.webgains.com/click.html?wgcampaignid=35257&wgprogramid=231&wgtarget=http://us.yesasia.com/en/PrdDept.aspx/code-w/section-videos/pid-1004826659 YesAsia.com]'''
* '''Buy now: [http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B000OPOAMU/102-4288925-5607313?ie=UTF8&tag=spaghetti-western-20&creativeASIN=B000OPOAMU From Amazon.com] | [http://track.webgains.com/click.html?wgcampaignid=35257&wgprogramid=231&wgtarget=http://us.yesasia.com/en/PrdDept.aspx/code-w/section-videos/pid-1004826659 YesAsia.com]'''
|}
|}
Line 39: Line 39:
|[[Image:gbuengl.jpg|114px|right]]
|[[Image:gbuengl.jpg|114px|right]]
* '''The Good, the Bad and the Ugly'''
* '''The Good, the Bad and the Ugly'''
* MGM 2 DVD Special Edition
* [[Global MGM DVD catalog|MGM]] 2 DVD Special Edition
* roughly similar to the Region 1 edition
* roughly similar to the Region 1 edition
*'''Buy now: [http://www.amazon.co.uk/exec/obidos/redirect?path=ASIN/B0001EYT2A&link_code=as2&camp=1634&tag=spaghetti-21&creative=6738 From Amazon.co.uk] | [http://track.webgains.com/click.html?wgcampaignid=35256&wgprogramid=376&clickref=GBU&wgtarget=http://www.moviemail-online.co.uk/films/9120/The_Good,_The_Bad_And_The_Ugly/ From MovieMail UK]'''
*'''Buy now: [http://www.amazon.co.uk/exec/obidos/redirect?path=ASIN/B0001EYT2A&link_code=as2&camp=1634&tag=spaghetti-21&creative=6738 From Amazon.co.uk] | [http://track.webgains.com/click.html?wgcampaignid=35256&wgprogramid=376&clickref=GBU&wgtarget=http://www.moviemail-online.co.uk/films/9120/The_Good,_The_Bad_And_The_Ugly/ From MovieMail UK]'''
Line 46: Line 46:
|-
|-
|[[Image:Swcol.jpg|right]]
|[[Image:Swcol.jpg|right]]
* Label: MGM
* Label: [[Global MGM DVD catalog|MGM]]
* Cardboard version (released 2005)
* Cardboard version (released 2005)
* '''Discs''': 6
* '''Discs''': 6
Line 56: Line 56:
|-
|-
|[[Image:Swcol2.jpg|right]]
|[[Image:Swcol2.jpg|right]]
* Label: MGM
* Label: [[Global MGM DVD catalog|MGM]]
* Steel Tin version (released 2007)
* Steel Tin version (released 2007)
* '''Discs''': 6
* '''Discs''': 6
Line 67: Line 67:
|-
|-
|
|
* Old MGM single disc edition
* Old [[Global MGM DVD catalog|MGM]] single disc edition
* '''Buy now: [http://www.amazon.it/gp/product/B00004RCL6?ie=UTF8&tag=spagh-21 From Amazon.it] |  [http://www.amazon.es/gp/product/B00004RCL6?ie=UTF8&tag=thespagwest01-21 Amazon.es] | [http://www.amazon.co.uk/gp/product/B00004RCL6?ie=UTF8&tag=spaghetti-21 Amazon.co.uk]'''
* '''Buy now: [http://www.amazon.it/gp/product/B00004RCL6?ie=UTF8&tag=spagh-21 From Amazon.it] |  [http://www.amazon.es/gp/product/B00004RCL6?ie=UTF8&tag=thespagwest01-21 Amazon.es] | [http://www.amazon.co.uk/gp/product/B00004RCL6?ie=UTF8&tag=spaghetti-21 Amazon.co.uk]'''
|-
|-
Line 78: Line 78:
* '''Zwei glorreiche Halunken'''
* '''Zwei glorreiche Halunken'''
* ''2-DVD Special Edition Steel box''
* ''2-DVD Special Edition Steel box''
* Label: MGM
* Label: [[Global MGM DVD catalog|MGM]]
* Same as below, but Steel case
* Same as below, but Steel case
* '''Buy now: [http://www.amazon.de/exec/obidos/redirect?path=ASIN/B000MGBMCM&tag=italowestern-21 From Amazon.de]'''
* '''Buy now: [http://www.amazon.de/exec/obidos/redirect?path=ASIN/B000MGBMCM&tag=italowestern-21 From Amazon.de]'''
Line 109: Line 109:
|[[Image:GBUalt1.jpg|right]]
|[[Image:GBUalt1.jpg|right]]
* ''This disc is CUT and offers only German audio. Not recommended due to bad quality.''
* ''This disc is CUT and offers only German audio. Not recommended due to bad quality.''
* Label: MGM
* Label: [[Global MGM DVD catalog|MGM]]
* Audio: German Mono
* Audio: German Mono
* Picture format: 4:3
* Picture format: 4:3
Line 119: Line 119:
|-
|-
|
|
* MGM/UA collection (single DVD)
* [[Global MGM DVD catalog|MGM]]/UA collection (single DVD)
* '''Buy now: [http://www.amazon.it/gp/product/B000176N5I?ie=UTF8&tag=spagh-21 From Amazon.it] | [http://www.amazon.es/gp/product/B000176N5I?ie=UTF8&tag=thespagwest01-21 Amazon.es]'''
* '''Buy now: [http://www.amazon.it/gp/product/B000176N5I?ie=UTF8&tag=spagh-21 From Amazon.it] | [http://www.amazon.es/gp/product/B000176N5I?ie=UTF8&tag=thespagwest01-21 Amazon.es]'''
|-
|-
Line 238: Line 238:
|[[Image:Gbuseaus.jpg|right|120px]]
|[[Image:Gbuseaus.jpg|right|120px]]
* '''The Good, the Bad and the Ugly'''
* '''The Good, the Bad and the Ugly'''
* Released by MGM / Fox, Region 4
* Released by [[Global MGM DVD catalog|MGM]] / Fox, Region 4
* Newer Ultimate Collector's Edition
* Newer Ultimate Collector's Edition
* Discs: 2
* Discs: 2
Line 249: Line 249:
|-
|-
|[[Image:Gbuaus.jpg|right|120px]]
|[[Image:Gbuaus.jpg|right|120px]]
* Released by MGM / Fox, Region 4
* Released by [[Global MGM DVD catalog|MGM]] / Fox, Region 4
* Older edition
* Older edition
|-
|-
Line 259: Line 259:
|[[File:Conflito.jpg|right|114px]] [[File:Conflitosilva.jpg|right|120px]]
|[[File:Conflito.jpg|right|114px]] [[File:Conflitosilva.jpg|right|120px]]
* '''Tres Homens em conflito''' - Edicao de Colecionador
* '''Tres Homens em conflito''' - Edicao de Colecionador
* MGM/Fox Home Video
* [[Global MGM DVD catalog|MGM]]Fox Home Video
* 2 Disc, Special Extended Edition
* 2 Disc, Special Extended Edition
* Audio: English 5.1, Portuguese and Spanish 2.0
* Audio: English 5.1, Portuguese and Spanish 2.0
Line 278: Line 278:
|-
|-
|[[File:Conflitofox.jpg|right|151px]] [[File:Conflitomgm.gif|right|120px]]
|[[File:Conflitofox.jpg|right|151px]] [[File:Conflitomgm.gif|right|120px]]
* Fox re-release of MGM disc (right), both widely available. Region 4
* Fox re-release of [[Global MGM DVD catalog|MGM]] disc (right), both widely available. Region 4
* Anamorphic Widescreen, NTSC
* Anamorphic Widescreen, NTSC
* Audio: English, Spanish, Portuguese
* Audio: English, Spanish, Portuguese
Line 289: Line 289:
|[[File:Trilogia.jpg|right|120px]]
|[[File:Trilogia.jpg|right|120px]]
* '''Trilogia do Homem Sem Nome'''
* '''Trilogia do Homem Sem Nome'''
* MGM/Fox Home Video
* [[Global MGM DVD catalog|MGM]]/Fox Home Video
* Includes all Films of the Dollar Trilogy. Exclusive to Livraria Cultura stores
* Includes all Films of the Dollar Trilogy. Exclusive to Livraria Cultura stores
* 3 Discs
* 3 Discs
Line 332: Line 332:
|[[File:Edicaospaghetti.jpg|right|120px]]
|[[File:Edicaospaghetti.jpg|right|120px]]
* Included in Coleçao Spaghetti Western box. Like the individual releases.
* Included in Coleçao Spaghetti Western box. Like the individual releases.
* MGM/Fox, Region 4, NTSC
* [[Global MGM DVD catalog|MGM]]/Fox, Region 4, NTSC
* Also includes:
* Also includes:
**[[Per qualche dollaro in più|Por uns dólares a Mais]]
**[[Per qualche dollaro in più|Por uns dólares a Mais]]
Line 345: Line 345:
|[[Image:gbupl.jpg|120px|right]]
|[[Image:gbupl.jpg|120px|right]]
* '''The Good, the Bad and the Ugly'''
* '''The Good, the Bad and the Ugly'''
* from MGM
* from [[Global MGM DVD catalog|MGM]]
|-
|-
|}
|}
Line 353: Line 353:
|-
|-
|
|
* from MGM (Region 3)
* from [[Global MGM DVD catalog|MGM]] (Region 3)
* This is the special edition
* This is the special edition
* Subtitles: English, Traditional Chinese, Korean, Thai, Bahasa (Indonesia), Portuguese
* Subtitles: English, Traditional Chinese, Korean, Thai, Bahasa (Indonesia), Portuguese

Revision as of 19:09, 8 July 2014

General comment: All recently released 2-DVD versions of this film by MGM are more or less identical. They vary in choice of language tracks offered, in packaging and in format (PAL/NTSC). They are all the same in terms of version and extras, so it is safe to say that you should order the version that suits you best.

Special Edition features identical on all versions: (Differences are noted under the specific disc) Commentary by film historian Richard Schickel | Leone's West | The Leone Style | The Man Who Lost the Civil War | Reconstructing The Good, The Bad and The Ugly | The Socorro Sequence reconstruction | Extended Tuco Torture Scene | Il Maestro, Parts 1 & 2 | French Trailer | Photo Gallery

USA

Gburerelease.jpg
  • The Good, The Bad And The Ugly
  • Re-issue (in line with the new box set) of the below version, but without the special packaging, booklet and postcards.
  • Label: MGM
  • Case: packaging altered to match the re-release of the other Leone films, content the same
  • Buy now: From Amazon.com | YesAsia.com
Gbu.jpg
  • This is a Special Collector's Edition. It is not out of print and was replaced by the version shown above. It is slightly superior due to the nicer packaging, booklet and post cards.
  • Label: MGM
  • Picture Format: 2.35:1 widescreen
  • Audio: English, Italian
  • Notable Differences: High-quality paper case, booklet by Richard Schickel, color postcards, original italian mono track
  • Buy now: From Amazon.com
Leoneboxusa2.jpg

UK

Gbuengl.jpg
Swcol.jpg
Swcol2.jpg
  • Label: MGM
  • Steel Tin version (released 2007)
  • Discs: 6
  • Includes the entire Dollar Trilogy Special Editions
  • Buy now: From Amazon.co.uk

Germany

ZweiGlorreicheSteel.jpg
  • Zwei glorreiche Halunken
  • 2-DVD Special Edition Steel box
  • Label: MGM
  • Same as below, but Steel case
  • Buy now: From Amazon.de
Halunken.jpg
  • This 2-DVD Gold Edition is out of print but is a recommended purchase
  • DVD Film Length: 171 min (PAL)
  • Picture format: 2.35:1 widescreen
  • Audio: German DD 5.1, English DD 5.1, French DD 5.1
  • Subtitles: German, English, French, Dutch, Portugese, Swedish etc.
  • Extras: Same as the others (see the extras box in the right upper corner)
  • see also: DVD review (deutsch)
  • Buy now: From Amazon.de
Szhalunken.jpg
  • This version is the remastered version, but no extras.
  • Label: Sueddeutsche Zeitung
  • The German daily newspaper Sueddeutsche Zeitung released a movie collection. Spine #68
  • Buy now: From Amazon.de
GBUalt1.jpg
  • This disc is CUT and offers only German audio. Not recommended due to bad quality.
  • Label: MGM
  • Audio: German Mono
  • Picture format: 4:3
  • Buy now: From Amazon.de
  • Cut Button.png

France

Bonbrute.jpg
Bonbrutetruandsimple.jpg
Frenchleonebox.jpg

Italy

Buono2.png


Cattivolibro.png
Capolavori.jpg

Spain

GBU filmax.jpg
  • El Bueno, el Feo y el Malo
  • From Filmax Pictures (2004)
  • Region 2 - PAL
  • Video: 2.35:1 - 16:9
  • Audio: Spanish DD 2.0, Italian DD 2.0
  • Subtitles: Spanish
  • Extras: Interview with Leone, deleted scenes
GBU Divisa.jpg
  • From Divisa Red (2002)
  • Region 0 - PAL
  • Video: 2.35:1 - 16:9
  • Audio: Spanish DD 5.1 stereo, Spanish DD 2.0 mono
  • Subtitles: Spanish
  • Runtime: 155 min
DollarTrilogy esp.jpg

Sweden

Gbuswedish.jpg
  • Den gode, den onde, den fule

Australia

Gbuseaus.jpg
  • The Good, the Bad and the Ugly
  • Released by MGM / Fox, Region 4
  • Newer Ultimate Collector's Edition
  • Discs: 2
  • Audio: English, German, French
  • Video: 2,35:1 anamorphic widescreen, PAL
Gbuaus.jpg
  • Released by MGM / Fox, Region 4
  • Older edition

Brazil

Conflito.jpg
Conflitosilva.jpg
  • Tres Homens em conflito - Edicao de Colecionador
  • MGMFox Home Video
  • 2 Disc, Special Extended Edition
  • Audio: English 5.1, Portuguese and Spanish 2.0
  • Extras like above, with Portuguese etc subtitles
  • Two different covers available, difference unclear, brown sleeve might be limited or sold out.
Conflitoduplo.jpg
  • Cinema Reserve collection. Fox, Region 4
  • 2 discs, specifications unknown
Conflitofox.jpg
Conflitomgm.gif
  • Fox re-release of MGM disc (right), both widely available. Region 4
  • Anamorphic Widescreen, NTSC
  • Audio: English, Spanish, Portuguese
  • 1 disc. 163 minutes
Trilogia.jpg
  • Trilogia do Homem Sem Nome
  • MGM/Fox Home Video
  • Includes all Films of the Dollar Trilogy. Exclusive to Livraria Cultura stores
  • 3 Discs
  • Region 4, NTSC, Widescreen
  • Audio: English, Spanish, Portuguese (DD 2.0)
  • Subtitles: Spanish, English, Portuguese
Bommaufeo.jpg
  • O Bom, O Mau E O Feio
  • Fullscreen, NTSC
  • English, Portuguese
  • by USA Discos, Region 4
  • Note: not recommended
Bommaufeo2.jpg
  • O Bom, O Mal E O Feio
  • Fullscreen, NTSC
  • Portuguese
  • by Gorgatti, Region 4
  • Note: not recommended
Leoneboxbrazil.jpg
  • Leone & Eastwood - Trilogia Dos Dolares
  • by Paragon Multimedia, Region 4, NTSC
  • includes complete Dollar Trilogy (Fullscreen, unconfirmed)
Edicaospaghetti.jpg
  • Included in Coleçao Spaghetti Western box. Like the individual releases.
  • MGM/Fox, Region 4, NTSC
  • Also includes:
  • Extras: Deleted Scenes (GBU only), Audio Commentary by Christopher Frayling (Dynamte only), Trailers

Poland

Gbupl.jpg
  • The Good, the Bad and the Ugly
  • from MGM

Hong Kong

  • from MGM (Region 3)
  • This is the special edition
  • Subtitles: English, Traditional Chinese, Korean, Thai, Bahasa (Indonesia), Portuguese
  • Buy now: From YesAsia.com
Retrieved from "https://www.spaghetti-western.net/index.php?title=Buono,_il_brutto,_il_cattivo,_Il/DVD&oldid=89562"
Cookies help us deliver our services. By using our services, you agree to our use of cookies.
More information