Difference between revisions of "Cry Onion (Cipolla Colt) Review"

From The Spaghetti Western Database

Line 1: Line 1:
 +
==Under Construction==
 +
 
{| align="right" style="border:1px solid black; padding:5px; margin:5px;" |
 
{| align="right" style="border:1px solid black; padding:5px; margin:5px;" |
 
|[[File:CipollaColtPos.jpg|230px]]
 
|[[File:CipollaColtPos.jpg|230px]]
Line 29: Line 31:
 
|[[File:Cipolla.jpg|200px]]
 
|[[File:Cipolla.jpg|200px]]
 
|}
 
|}
Okay, maybe this comedy spaghetti is not as bad as it’s reputed to be, but don’t forget that it’s often called one the worst ever. It was directed by the man behind Johnny Hamlet and Keoma, written by two of the best screenwriters in the business, and stars Mr. Django himself, but the result is a stinker about the fastest Onion in the West. Franco Nero is Onion Jack a man who virtually lives among the onions. He eats them, drinks them, and even uses them to defend himself. He’s in possession of a gun, but basically uses his onions to ''throw'', ''squeeze'' and ''breathe'' his opponents out. Jack has bought a piece of land and now wants to settle down and cultivate his beloved onions, but there are a few complications: two orphans of the original owner pop up, in posession of a lease which identifies them as the legal owners, and the property is coveted by the evil oil prospector Petrus Lamb, who has already driven all other inhabitants of the valley off their lands.   
+
Okay, maybe this comedy spaghetti is not as bad as it’s reputed to be, but don’t forget that it’s often called one of the worst ever. It was directed by the man behind [[Quella sporca storia nel west|Johnny Hamlet]] and [[Keoma]], written by two of the best screenwriters in the business, and stars Mr. Django himself, but the result is a stinker about the fastest Onion in the West. Franco Nero is Onion Jack a man who virtually lives among the onions. He eats them, drinks them, and even uses them to defend himself. He’s in possession of a gun, but basically uses his onions to ''throw'', ''squeeze'' and ''breathe'' his opponents out. Jack has bought a piece of land and now wants to settle down and cultivate his beloved onions, but there are a few complications: two orphans of the original owner pop up, in posession of a lease which identifies them as the legal owners, and the property is coveted by the evil oil prospector Petrus Lamb, who has already driven all other inhabitants of the valley off their lands.   
  
  
The story by Sergio Donati and Luciano Vincenzoni is a sort of rewriting of [[C'era una volta il West|Once Upon a Time in the West]] in the style of a spoof. Nero has been given a curly perm to make him look like Terence Hill (or maybe his poodle), while his horse seems modeled after Luky Luke’s famous four-footed friend Jolly Jumper: he has been given the capacity to communicate and I’m sure he’d beat his boss at chess. People have either silly names or silly characteristics: Jack gets some assistance from a newspaperman called Pulitzer, and the corrupt oil prospector has a robotic hand, and an employee with a Hitler moustache (and a Jewish name, Benjamin!). Martin Balsam hams it up as the evil Petrus Lamb (a miracle they didn’t call him Agnus Dei), but Sterling Hayden (once Johnny Guitar) plays his newspaperman with an ironed face. Balsam often made the trip to Europe in the course of the seventies (apparently he had the right face to play in mafia movies), but it was Hayden’s only appearance in an Italian genre movie; he was in Italy for Bertolucci’s Novecento, and probably had no idea in what kind of movie he had ended up. Among the genre regulars are Leo Anchoriz, Romano Puppo and Dan van Husen, all in silly parts. Giusti claims that Castellerai made a guest appearance in his own movie, but I haven’t spotted him.  
+
The story by Sergio Donati and Luciano Vincenzoni is a sort of rewriting of [[C'era una volta il West|Once Upon a Time in the West]] in the style of a spoof. Nero has been given a curly perm to make him look like Terence Hill (or maybe his poodle), while his horse seems modeled after Luky Luke’s famous four-footed friend Jolly Jumper: he has been given the capacity to communicate and I’m sure he’d beat his boss at chess. People have either silly names or silly characteristics: Jack gets some assistance from a newspaperman called ''Pulitzer'', and the corrupt oil prospector has a robotic hand, and an employee with a Hitler moustache (and a Jewish name, Benjamin!). Martin Balsam hams it up as the evil ''Petrus Lamb'' (a miracle they didn’t call him ''Agnus Dei''), but Sterling Hayden (once Johnny Guitar) plays his newspaperman with an ironed face. Balsam often made the trip to Europe in the course of the seventies (apparently he had the right face to play in ''mafia'' movies), but it was Hayden’s only appearance in an Italian genre movie; he was in Italy for Bertolucci’s ''Novecento'', and probably had no idea in what kind of movie he had ended up. Among the genre regulars are Leo Anchoriz, Romano Puppo and Dan van Husen, all in silly parts. Giusti claims that Castellerai made a guest appearance in his own movie, but I haven’t spotted him.  
  
  
There are also a few good things to say about it. Alejandro Ulloa’s cinematography is excellent (as always) and most scenes are well-directed by Castellari. It also speaks in the movie’s favor that it’s not merely a copy of the Trinity formula. It’s often closer to Carnimeo than Barboni, but with its speeded-up chase scenes and anachronistic elements such as bikers and Balsam as a sort of Dr. Strangelove out West, it tries to find a personal tone. It all could have worked, and it occasionally does, but overall it not funny enough. It seems to me Nero wasn’t a good choice for the part. He was one of the coolest actors of his generation, but not one of the most athletic. The speeded-up chase scene in which Nero tries to escape from his persecutors on a bike is well-executed, but Benny Hill has ruined the idea a little over the years; I noticed that I was hoping for scantily dressed beautiful women to pop up at any moment, but no, this was a movie aimed at the entire family, not just daddy.  
+
There are also a few ''good'' things to say about it. Alejandro Ulloa’s cinematography is excellent (as always) and most scenes are well-directed by Castellari. It also speaks in the movie’s favor that it’s not merely a copy of the Trinity formula. It’s often closer to Carnimeo than Barboni, but with its speeded-up chase scenes and anachronistic elements such as bikers and Balsam as a sort of ''Dr. Strangelove out West'', it tries to find a personal tone. It all could have worked, and it occasionally does, but overall it not funny enough. It seems to me Nero wasn’t a good choice for the part. He was one of the coolest actors of his generation, but not one of the most athletic. Some of the fistfights therefore fall flat. The speeded-up chase scene in which Nero tries to escape from his persecutors on a bike is well-executed, but ''Benny Hill'' has ruined the idea a little over the years; I noticed that I was hoping for scantily dressed beautiful women to pop up at any moment, but no, this was a movie aimed at the entire family, not just daddy.  
  
  

Revision as of 12:34, 15 April 2011

Under Construction

CipollaColtPos.jpg
CRY ONION / CIPOLLA COLT (1975)
Director:
  • Enzo G. Castellari

Cast:

  • Franco Nero
  • Martin Balsam
  • Sterling Hayden
  • Leo Anchóriz
  • Dick Butkus
  • Romano Puppo
  • Emma Cohen
  • Charley Bravo
  • Georges Rigaud
  • Dan van Husen

Music:

  • Guido & Maurizio De Angelis

Cry Onion (Cipolla Colt)

View database Page


Cipolla.jpg

Okay, maybe this comedy spaghetti is not as bad as it’s reputed to be, but don’t forget that it’s often called one of the worst ever. It was directed by the man behind Johnny Hamlet and Keoma, written by two of the best screenwriters in the business, and stars Mr. Django himself, but the result is a stinker about the fastest Onion in the West. Franco Nero is Onion Jack a man who virtually lives among the onions. He eats them, drinks them, and even uses them to defend himself. He’s in possession of a gun, but basically uses his onions to throw, squeeze and breathe his opponents out. Jack has bought a piece of land and now wants to settle down and cultivate his beloved onions, but there are a few complications: two orphans of the original owner pop up, in posession of a lease which identifies them as the legal owners, and the property is coveted by the evil oil prospector Petrus Lamb, who has already driven all other inhabitants of the valley off their lands.


The story by Sergio Donati and Luciano Vincenzoni is a sort of rewriting of Once Upon a Time in the West in the style of a spoof. Nero has been given a curly perm to make him look like Terence Hill (or maybe his poodle), while his horse seems modeled after Luky Luke’s famous four-footed friend Jolly Jumper: he has been given the capacity to communicate and I’m sure he’d beat his boss at chess. People have either silly names or silly characteristics: Jack gets some assistance from a newspaperman called Pulitzer, and the corrupt oil prospector has a robotic hand, and an employee with a Hitler moustache (and a Jewish name, Benjamin!). Martin Balsam hams it up as the evil Petrus Lamb (a miracle they didn’t call him Agnus Dei), but Sterling Hayden (once Johnny Guitar) plays his newspaperman with an ironed face. Balsam often made the trip to Europe in the course of the seventies (apparently he had the right face to play in mafia movies), but it was Hayden’s only appearance in an Italian genre movie; he was in Italy for Bertolucci’s Novecento, and probably had no idea in what kind of movie he had ended up. Among the genre regulars are Leo Anchoriz, Romano Puppo and Dan van Husen, all in silly parts. Giusti claims that Castellerai made a guest appearance in his own movie, but I haven’t spotted him.


There are also a few good things to say about it. Alejandro Ulloa’s cinematography is excellent (as always) and most scenes are well-directed by Castellari. It also speaks in the movie’s favor that it’s not merely a copy of the Trinity formula. It’s often closer to Carnimeo than Barboni, but with its speeded-up chase scenes and anachronistic elements such as bikers and Balsam as a sort of Dr. Strangelove out West, it tries to find a personal tone. It all could have worked, and it occasionally does, but overall it not funny enough. It seems to me Nero wasn’t a good choice for the part. He was one of the coolest actors of his generation, but not one of the most athletic. Some of the fistfights therefore fall flat. The speeded-up chase scene in which Nero tries to escape from his persecutors on a bike is well-executed, but Benny Hill has ruined the idea a little over the years; I noticed that I was hoping for scantily dressed beautiful women to pop up at any moment, but no, this was a movie aimed at the entire family, not just daddy.


Cipolla5.jpg Cipolla4.jpg Cipolla2.jpg


--By Scherpschutter

  • Newsletter
  • Giallo
  • Spaghetti Western books
  • Arrow Video