The Return of Ringo Review (Scherpschutter)
From The Spaghetti Western Database
The Return of Ringo (Il Ritorno di Ringo)
In The Return of Ringo, the legendary Giuliano Gemma is Montgomery Brown, knick-named Ringo, a man who comes back from the war. While making a stop in a bar on his way home, he outdraws two hired killers, sent out to stop him. He is told that the region is terrorized by a gang of Mexicans, led by the two Fuentes brothers, racists who think Americans are an inferior race and therefore not allowed to carry firearms. The brothers have killed his father and taken over the family properties; the younger of the two, Paco has also planned to marry his wife and become the foster father of his daughter, who was born in his absence. To find out if his wife has remained faithful to him, Ringo dyes his hair and enters the town incognito ...
The screenplay for this movie was loosely based on the final chapters of Homer's Odyssey, about the hero Odysseus' homecoming after the Trojan War. Many Italian directors and screenwriters used the American Civil War and its aftermath as a substitute for World war II, to tell something about the Italian post-war society: Italy was a wounded society, torn apart, humiliated, trying to redefine itself. The movie enormous success among Italian audiences (it premiered in December 1965 and made more than a billion lire until the end of the year) is easily explained by the fact that the Italians knew exactly what this film was about: it was more than just a western movie, the hero more than just a proud man fighting for his ranch and family.
Return of Ringo is usually presented as a sequel, but on story level the connection between the two Ringo movies is rather loose. The first movie is a fairly light-hearted (if violent) variation on Per un pugni di dollari|A Fistful of dollars, with Gemma playing a passer-by who interferes in a conflict. The second is a much darker movie, thematically richer and more deeply felt; moreover it's a revenge movie. The Ringo from Pistola is a carefree, charming young man, a bit of a cynic, but deep down inside he's a decent man, a rascal maybe, but one with a heart of gold. The Ringo who comes back from the war is an embittered man, desperate, but wearing his emotional scars with dignity and pride. He's humiliated, symbolically emasculated (his wife stolen, his shooting hand pierced) but right from the start we understand that he will not be broken.
The connection with A Fistful of Dollars (Tessari had been one of the screenwriters) is still strong: like No Name, Ringo shows his remarkable proficiency with the gun early on, but he will have to suffer before he can take his revenge in the explosive finale. There's also a Piripero type of character, played by Spanish actor Pajarito, but he's not a coffin maker this time, but a florist (Ringo goes undercover as his assistant!). There's also still this influence of Hollywood westerns both Leone and Tessari loved, in particular Rio Bravo: like John Wayne's character, it takes Ringo only a few friends (plus his own skills) to overcome his seemingly insurmountable problems. The sheriff played by Antonio Casas is a cardboard copy of Dean Martin's Dude, Pajarito takes the place of Walter Brennan's stumpy, and Nieves Navarro is a slightly more cunning, shrewd variation on Angie Dickinson's Feathers: instead of a tart with a heart, she has become a fortune teller whose sympathies are as changeable as the predictions of her oracle cards.
Most of this was more or less familiar, but in telling a story about a war veteran trying to pick up his life, who must fight for his home and family in the post-war society, Il Ritorno the Ringo added a new dimension to the genre. Stories about people trying to pick up their lives again after the war, had been a recurrent theme in neo-realism, for instance in Vittorio De Sica's landmark movie Ladri di Bicicletti (Bycicle Thieves). But it was new that similar themes were expressed through the medium of genre cinema: in this sense, Il Ritorno di Ringo is a landmark movie. The slightly similar One Silver dollar (also starring Gemma) was released a few months earlier, but it was Tessari's movie that set the standard for, and became the blueprint of these type of movies, one of the most enduring (and highly regarded) subgenres within the genre of the spaghetti westerns. The list of movies set in the aftermath of the Civil War is long. Some of the first spaghetti westerns as well as some of the last - like Keoma (1976) and California (1977) - are cast in this mould.
The title director Tessari had in mind for his movie, was L'Odissea dei lunghi fucili, that is: The Odyssey of the Long Rifles, but the producers convinced Tessari to change it into Il Ritorno di Ringo. However, it's not clear when this decision was made; there is a lot of confusion about when (and even in what order) the two Ringo movies were made (*). Some think the two Ringo movies were made back to back, others think they're separated by months and Gemma made Un Dollaro Bucato (with director Ferroni) between the two Ringo movies. Both Ringos have virtually the same cast, but with actors in (often radically) different roles. The best adjustment in this aspect, is the casting of Daniel Martin (who had been in bland sheriff in Pistola) as Paco Fuentes, the younger but more evil of the two Mexican brothers. Loretta De Luca (Mrs. Tessari) also has a better, more complex role as the confused woman who thinks she's a widow: she still loves her 'late' husband but might also have some feelings for the brutish but attractive Paco. The grand finale, with Ringo and his private army attacking the Brown villa, is a bit disappointing, and but some scenes belong to the very best this genre has to offer: the fake funeral, Ringo watching his own interment, Gemma walking down the street town, seen through decorative sections of glass in different colors, turning him into the image of a Saint in leadlight windows, and above all Gemma's appearance (or better: reappearance) in the middle of a sandstorm:
"I am Montgomery Brown, and I have returned."